So simplifying our environment, though still a work in progress, wasn't that hard to do. Like I said, it had been on our minds for a while, it was aesthetically pleasing (less clutter!) and practical (less stuff to clean up!), and it yielded immediate results. (Yesterday, I stepped outside and heard a casual, "Hey, Mom," from Sam. Except it was coming from a tree; from really high up in a tree. And you know why? Because I got rid of the Leapster, and the Tinker Toys, and the train tracks, and the play food, and the Mighty Beans, and I bored him right out of the house and up a tree. Way up a tree. And I never saw him look so proud of a Mr. Potato Head or pleased with a plastic light saber, and so I think perhaps we did the right thing.)
With our home environment well-on-its-way, we tackled the part of this whole simplification process that scared me the most: Routine.
We're just...not schedule people. Here are some questions to which I have historically had to make up answers on the spot:
What time do your kids go to bed? What time do your kids get up? When do your kids take their bath? What time does the baby nap? How frequently does she nurse? What time do you eat dinner?
The true answers to those questions are: Whenever, whenever, when they're dirty, whenever, when she wants to, whenever. I typically answered a little more indirectly: "Last night they were up pretty late," "Lucie always wakes up early; the other two like to sleep in a bit," "Before bed, usually, or whenever they hear me about to get in the bath," "It changes," "Which one?" and "Six?"
We're not schedule people. And I'll admit, it's mostly me. I just like to find some more compelling reason to do a given thing than because it's that time. I like to eat when I'm hungry, and sleep when I'm tired. And I like my kids to do the same. And sometimes, this is a really good thing. People often ask how I can tolerate being on-call for births, and I think, "No, how do you tolerate getting up at the same time every day, to go to the same place, with the same people, to do the same job, for the same number of hours, just to come home at the same time, to eat-shower-sleep so you can do it all again tomorrow?"
The problem is, there are five of us here. And it turns out, we don't all get tired at the same time. Or hungry. And it looks like Sam is going to start kindergarten in a few weeks. It starts at the same time every morning. And it's an early time.
So when I opened to the chapter of Simplicity Parenting on routines and schedules, I paused. And I took a deep breath. And I decided to just hear him out, so to speak.
It turns out--surprise, surprise--that Payne thinks routine (he uses the word "rhythm" which, I agree, is favorable) is really fantastic for kids. That predictability helps cut down on resistance. I knew I had to start putting my kids to bed at some particular time, but Payne takes it a lot further. He suggests incorporating monotony rhythm into every aspect of your (and your child's) day. He goes so far as to suggest a meal-schedule in which the day of the week determines what's for dinner. Ridiculous. And, yet, we decided to give it a try.
We started while we were up north. With two available parents, it was a lot easier to tackle the children, put them in bed and sit on them until they finally lost consciousness task of guiding our heretofore scheduleless children into a new routine--one that would no doubt feel rigid. And unnatural. And one that they were bound to resist.
We began with bedtime. My kids were used to going to bed sometime between 10:00 and 11:00, so I reached into the sky and pulled out a ridiculously arbitrary time, 7:30, and declared it "bedtime." In case you're reading this from Alaska, or Jupiter, I will mention: 7:30 in July in Michigan looks an awful lot like day time. It's been getting dark around 10 lately. So a 7:30 bedtime was sort of setting ourselves up for failure. Still, at 7:00 or so, we told the kids it was time to brush their teeth and get their pajamas on, and they looked at us like it was some sort of joke they just didn't quite get, and they got in bed, and I sat down to read Harry Potter to them at about 7:15. By 7:30, Lucie was asleep. I read for about 45-60 minutes to Sam, and then told him goodnight and left the room. And he went to sleep. And the next morning, they were up between 6:45 and 7:00 (and I rolled out of bed shortly after). And that night, we did it again. And it worked. And again. And again. And several weeks later, my kids are in bed by 8:00 every night, sleeping away in broad daylight. And they sleep until a bit after 7:00, which is about
when they'll need to wake up this fall in order for us to get Sam to kindergarten by 8:25, and Lucie to preschool by 8:35.
And now I'm going to say exactly what you think I'm going to say: It's been a really wonderful change. Joel and I now sometimes have whole conversations where we say all the words and don't have to spell anything (which is weird, but I'm sure we'll get used to it). We play board games. We make salsa out of our CSA veggies--way too spicy for the kids, but it doesn't matter, because we don't have to share with them. We drink smoothies. Or sometimes, I go hang out with friends, all by myself. Or sometimes, and this is really crazy, we go to bed sort of...at a "reasonable" hour.
At first, we just focussed on the "big" kids, but we're slowly working Fiona into the routine, as well. And it's working.
Bedtime was the biggest (and most frightening) change to our routine that we made, and the one with which we've had the most success, but it isn't the only change we've made (or are working on). We've been trying to incorporate a bit more "rhythm" or routine into the rest of our days, too.
One thing that we're trying (with varying degrees of success) is Payne's suggestion of eating the same (general) thing for a given night of the week. So, for instance, eating soup (any kind of soup!) on Tuesday, or fish on Friday. Here's what we're shooting for (and like I said, I'm not *always* successful):
Monday--Pasta
Tuesday--Soup
Wednesday--Fish or Chicken
Friday--Pizza
I left the weekends alone, because I knew they would be the time when it was most difficult for us to stay consistent. The problem I've found is that, for example, when friends invited us over for an impromptu dinner of enchiladas on Tuesday, I just couldn't say, "Oooh, no-can-do! It's Soup Night!" because (a) we like spending time with our friends, (b) if our friends caught wind of "Soup Night" we might not have any friends and (c) enchiladas are delicious.
It is sort of a fun idea, though, and it actually makes meal planning more fun for me. Just as I enjoy the challenge of trying to use whatever vegetables we receive from our CSA in a given week, it's sort of fun to look for a new soup recipe for soup night, or to come up with a creative pasta dish. And the pizza night, which probably sounds like the biggest cop-out ever, is actually really fun as well--using our fresh veggies to make interesting pizzas (while allowing ourselves the freedom, I'll admit, of going out for pizza if we just don't feel like it) is lots of fun.
When CSA pepper explosion meets Pizza Night, you get pizza-that-will-burn-your-lips-off.
Payne says that mealtimes (and bedtime) are some of the biggest points-of-conflict with small children, and that these mealtime routines (and others) can help to alleviate some of that stress. Actually, for us, mealtime doesn't typically cause a lot of grief, and so the pay-off of adapting this meal schedule is pretty minimal, and I suspect it won't stick for long, or that we'll never be terribly consistent with it. Nonetheless, it's been fun to try, and I'll think we'll keep with it for a while.
Payne makes some other interesting suggestions, some of which we may try at some point. One suggestion he made was that there be some sort of ritual that precedes mealtime, such as a prayer, a poem, a song, et cetera. We're not a praying family, a pre-meal song feels embarrassing to even think about, and Joel might jump ship on this whole experiment if I asked him to refrain from eating while I read poetry to the family. But Payne mentioned that his family began observing a period of silence before they ate--beginning with just 10-15 seconds, and gradually working up to a minute or so. That sounds sort of nice (actually, if my kids eyes were open and they were silent for 60 consecutive seconds, I would probably assume I'd gone deaf), and perhaps we'll eventually try that.
Payne also suggested similar sing-songy rituals around other daily activities: hand washing, room cleaning, hair brushing, et cetera. It's not for me, but I see its merit. Sort of. I'm just never going to sing "brush, brush, brush your teeth" or whatever. But if you want to try it, do! I'd be interested to hear how it goes for you, and I totally wouldn't make fun of you! (One of those statements is true.)
And even though changing bedtime was just one of many ideas we got from Simplicity Parenting, that one change set into motion a sort of domino effect in our house. Most notably, we're getting up earlier. And not just Lucie (who has always gotten up early); all of us. Which means that Lucie is (a) getting more sleep and (b) being a little better...received...in the morning. This results in a much nicer Lucie who, although still prone to the occasional outburst (she is three, after all) is seeming altogether more stable than she was a month ago. We're eating dinner at a more consistent time, since we know that it needs to happen before teeth can be brushed, and baths taken, and PJs donned--and all of this needs to happen by a particular time. A bedtime. And, like I said, this means more time for Joel and I to be adults. Which is pretty great.
So far, so good.
Happy Pizza Night, Everyone!